All episodes

In 1973, a strange creature reportedly terrorized the small town of Enfield, Illinois. Henry McDaniel claimed he encountered a bizarre, three-legged monster outside his home—and the story quickly became a national sensation. But when sociologists investigated, they discovered something stranger than a monster: how rumors become legends.

In 1955, a Kentucky family claimed they were attacked for hours by strange, silver-gray creatures. The Kelly-Hopkinsville Encounter became one of America’s most famous alleged alien encounters. But how much of the story is actually true? We separate eyewitness accounts from rumors, myths, and decades of UFO lore.

Deep in the English countryside lurks Black Annis, a blue-faced hag said to devour children. But behind the terrifying legend lie real historical clues, a mysterious cave, and a medieval recluse named Agnes Scott. What’s the truth behind this infamous monster?