All episodes

Host Josh Peck rings in the holidays by welcoming Christmas carolers Brianne, Matt, and Ohona to a 100-year-old tavern famous for its long-standing tradition of caroling. Virtuoso baker April Julian has disguised six delectable sweets as everyday tavern objects, and it's up to this squad of singers to hunt down each sweet creation for a shot at winning up to $12,000.

Host Josh Peck and cake artist Jose Barajas welcome three moms who know a thing or two about shopping for the holidays. These biters have spent years hunting down the season's must-have toys, but now their shopping expertise is being put to the ultimate test. Hidden throughout this festive toy store are six hyperrealistic sweets disguised as everyday toys. Across four increasingly difficult rounds, the moms must study their surroundings, examine the finest details, and decide which items are real toys and which are sweet treats in disguise. Every correct bite brings them closer to winning up to $12,000 for their families' holiday wish lists -- but will these savvy shoppers find the sweets before they get deceived?

Hosted by Josh Peck, Santa, Mrs. Claus, and their Elf are on a mission to hunt for sweets! A family of three takes over a shopping mall Santa's Village, where expert baker JonnyCakes has transformed six ordinary-looking holiday props into astonishingly realistic cakes. Through four increasingly challenging rounds, the family must inspect their festive surroundings, spot the objects that don't quite belong, and take a bite to uncover the truth. With up to $12,000 at stake, can this holiday trio see through JonnyCakes' sweet deceptions, or will they get fooled before Christmas comes?

Host Josh Peck welcomes three coworkers from an art supply company to put their eye for detail to the ultimate test. Carlee, Skyler, and Jared are used to working with color, texture, and fine detail, but they've never had to use those talents to spot desserts in disguise. World-class baker Ashley Holt has transformed an office holiday party into a winter wonderland of secret sweets, with six hyperrealistic cakes hidden in plain sight. Across four increasingly difficult rounds, the trio must study their surroundings, compare notes, and prove their suspicions the only way that counts -- by taking a bite. Every correct guess brings them closer to winning up to $12,000, but with so much festive clutter to sort through, will their trained artistic eyes help them find the sweets, or will they get sweetly deceived?

Bennett, Brielle, and Kaylen have been skating together for years, but nothing on the ice has prepared them for this. Host Josh Peck welcomes the trio into a crowded ice rink where everything looks normal, yet six of the objects around them are actually sweets made by Jose Barajas, a baker whose creations fool even the sharpest eyes. Through four rounds that grow more difficult as they go, the friends must study their surroundings, compare notes, and commit to a bite when they think they've spotted a fake. Guess right and they move closer to winning $12,000 -- but with each wrong pick, they're tasting defeat instead of dessert.

Host Josh Peck heads back to school and meets up with teachers Celina, Jenni, and Vanessa inside a cheerful classroom transformed for a Christmas party! Hidden among the clutter and holiday decorations, virtuoso baker April Julian has stashed six cleverly disguised sweets that look just like everyday schoolroom objects. This trio of educators will need sharp eyes and plenty of holiday spirit to spot the sweets and jingle all the way home with $12,000.